Radio live 24 hours

List Widget

Max CPC Domains yahoo $97.44 Domain name yahoo $79.81 Dc hair laser removal washington $68.91 Law lemon wisconsin $66.15 Hair removal washington dc $51.14 Domain registration yahoo $41.97 Benchmark lending $40.36 Domain yahoo $38.05 Yahoo web hosting $37.86 Hair laser removal virginia $37.29 Peritoneal mesothelioma $36.59 Ca lemon law $36.55 Best buy gift card $34.13 Adverse credit remortgage $31.10 Mesothelioma information $30.98 Law lemon ohio $29.77 Att call conference $29.34 Insurance medical temporary $29.10 Illinois law lemon $28.95 Mesothelioma symptoms $28.78 Angeles drug los rehab $28.51 Personal injury solicitor $28.26 Att go $28.23 Accident car florida lawyer $28.03 Google affiliate $27.11 At t wireless $27.11 100 home equity loan $26.31 Mcsa boot camp $26.28 Anti spam appliance $26.19 Adverse remortgage $26.17 Chicago hair laser removal $26.00 Att conference $25.98 At and t $25.84 Laser hair removal maryland $25.45 Mesothelioma $25.15 Buy gift card $24.88 Mesotheloma $24.80 Student loan consolidation program $24.52 California law lemon $24.45 Event management security $24.30 Canada personals yahoo $24.15 Orlando criminal attorney $24.15 Uk homeowner loans $23.78 Vioxx lawsuit $23.71 Mesothelioma $23.65 Compare life assurance $23.55 Criminal defense federal lawyer $23.34 American singles $23.29 Federal criminal defense attorney $23.09 Laser hair removal manhattan $23.07 Att prepaid wireless $23.03 Fortis health insurance temporary $23.00 Miami personal injury lawyer $22.93 Hair removal chicago $22.75 At and t cell phones $22.74 Refinance with bad credit $22.61 Malignant mesothelioma $22.47 Lease management software $22.45 Primary pulmonary hypertension $22.34 Miami personal injury attorney $22.27 Anti spam lotus notes $22.24 Life insurance quotes $22.23 Egg credit $21.91 Anti spam exchange server $21.80 Lemon law $21.77 Google adsense $21.67 Best consolidation loan student $21.67 Refinance with poor credit $21.63 Employee leasing $21.49 Student loan consolidation center $21.36 Buyer mortgage note $21.35 Federal student loan consolidation $21.34 Symptoms of mesothelioma $21.33 City hair laser new removal york $21.31 Att wireless com $21.20 San diego dui lawyer $21.15 Indiana law lemon $21.14 Structured settlement $21.05 Law lemon michigan $21.10 Angeles criminal defense los $20.80 Refinancing with poor credit $20.80 Home equity loan $20.64 Action class lawsuit vioxx $20.64 Term life assurance $20.49 E loan $20.47 Celebrex lawyer $20.46 Vasectomy reversal $20.37 Mortgage rates refinancing $20.36 Attorney law lemon $20.28 Consolidate student loans $20.28 Home equity loans $20.17 Mesothilioma $20.11 New york personal injury lawyer $19.99 Home equity loan rates $19.98 Auto insurance quotes $19.97 Georgia law lemon $19.93 Homeowner loans $19.90 Equity loan rates $19.73 Administration lease software $19.68 Egg credit card $19.63 Student consolidation loans $19.58 Microsoft anti spam $19.55 Mesothelioma prognosis $19.41 Second mortgages $19.29 21 auto century insurance $19.26 Employee florida leasing $19.25 Federal consolidation loan $19.21 Equity loan $19.17 Personal injury attorney colorado $19.14 Accident lawyer michigan $19.03 Refinancing with bad credit $19.02 Home equity line of credit rates $19.02 Federal consolidation $19.01 Non profit debt consolidation $18.96 Pay per click affiliate $18.95 City hair new removal york $18.86 Acid reflux disease diet $18.85 Refinance poor credit $18.77 Equity loans $18.75 Student loan consolidate $18.73 Consolidate loans $18.60 Secured loans $18.51 Criminal lawyer new york $18.49 Affiliate per click $18.43 Chicago personal injury lawyer $18.29 Los angeles dui lawyer $18.29 Att prepaid $18.19 Angeles criminal defense lawyer los $18.10 Critical illness insurance life $18.04 Irs lawyer tax $18.03 Laser hair removal new york $18.03 Comcast high speed $18.02 Personal yahoo $17.98 San diego dui attorney $17.78 Michigan personal injury $17.77 Automobile law lemon $17.73 Cheap insurance life term $17.66 Home loans refinancing $17.52 Consolidate college loans $17.51 Cheap life insurance $17.45 Vioxx law suit $17.38 Student loan refinance $17.32 Car hire alicante spain $17.30 Tax attorney $17.28 Refinancing my home $17.28 Criminal dallas lawyer $17.24 Line of credit home equity $17.24 Litigation vioxx $17.23 At and t phones $17.20 Criminal defense attorney los angeles $17.15 Commodity online trading $17.14 Home equity rates $17.13 Adsense $17.12 Law lemon mass $17.12 Equity home $17.11 Arizona law lemon $17.10 Child molestation attorney $17.09 Home line of credit $17.09 Alicante car rental spain $17.06 Attorney defense federal $17.03 San diego criminal attorney $17.02 Injury lawyer new york $16.79 Attorney injury new personal york $16.78 At and t mobile $16.77 Pleural mesothelioma $16.72 Augmentation breast diego san $16.61 Home equity poor credit $16.61 Health insurance temporary $16.60 Compensation mesothelioma $16.60 21st century insurance $16.60 Cheap insurance medical $16.52 Angeles criminal lawyer los $16.51 Low cost term life insurance $16.49 Home refinance loans $16.48 Eloan $16.45 Life insurance quote $16.44 Cheap life assurance $16.39 125 equity loan $16.33 Anti spam exchange $16.32 Credit equity home line $16.31 Att go phone $16.30 Dui florida lawyer $16.30 Hair removal new york $16.27 Merchant account international $16.14 Vioxx class action $16.11 125 home equity loan $16.10 Life insurance quote online $16.10 Consolidation loan $16.09 Equity line of credit $16.04 Carolina law lemon north $16.02 Equity rates $16.02 Direct home insurance line $15.87 Angeles attorney los tax $15.86 Credit home line $15.85 Term insurance $15.81 Auto insurances $15.81 Debtfreedirect $15.80 Refinance comparison $15.80 Acid reflux treatment $15.77 Bad credit mortgage refinance $15.77 College loan refinance $15.73

Debunking the latest from the New York Times on “smaller” government spending

10:03 PM // 0 comments // Unknown // Category: USA news

The government is getting smaller under President Obama, proclaimed an astonishing headline in the New York Times last Friday. Really?

For the first time in 40 years, the government sector of the American economy has shrunk during the first three years of a presidential administration.

Spending by the federal government, adjusted for inflation, has risen at a slow rate under President Obama. But that increase has been more than offset by a fall in spending by state and local governments, which have been squeezed by weak tax receipts.

In the first quarter of this year, the real gross domestic product for the government — including state and local governments as well as federal — was 2 percent lower than it was three years earlier, when Barack Obama took office in early 2009.

The story includes a link to a series of charts showing the growth rate in the Gross Domestic Product (GDP), and the government spending component of GDP, under President Obama compared to prior administrations dating back to the first Bush presidency. But the key chart is this one:

It took me a while to figure this out, but what they’ve done is plotted the percentage change in GDP and government spending relative to what the total was at the end of the first quarter of 2009. So the totals at the end of the President’s first quarter in office were used as the baseline to which all subsequent quarters through the end of March 2012 were compared to. This explains why the rate of GDP growth in the chart above (the black line) is shown exceeding 5% when it has never exceeded 4% for any quarter under President Obama, and has been no higher than 3% since early 2010. These figures are based on cumulative totals, computing the net percentage change in GDP since the end of March 2009. The cumulative increase in GDP over the last 3 years is actually 6.6%, which represents very stagnant growth on a historical basis.

The brown line in the chart then represents the percentage change in the government spending component of GDP since March 2009; and in fact, the total for the first quarter of 2012 was 2% lower than the total for the same quarter in 2009.

If you are confused by all this perhaps that’s what the Times intended because their data is misleading in a couple of critical ways. First and foremost, total government spending adjusted for inflation was actually higher on a calendar-year basis for 2009, 2010, and 2011 when compared to 2008, or any other year of the Bush administration. The only actual reduction in overall spending came in 2011 when spending declined by $54B relative to 2010, but the mid-term elections undoubtedly had a lot to do with this.

The Times piece is also misleading because by focusing on GDP, their data includes only direct government expenditures on goods, services, and investments, while leaving out two key categories which now make up well over 50% of total government spending: transfer and interest payments. Government transfer payments (e.g. Social Security, Medicare, food stamps) have increased by over 15% from March 2009 to March 2012, and interest payments on government debt have increased by over 30% (neither figure is adjusted for inflation). This spending ultimately shows up in the private sector for the purposes of computing GDP, but would normally be included in any discussion about the growth in government spending.

Even excluding interest and transfer payments (which really shouldn’t be excluded), the Times’ assertion that federal spending has “risen at a slow rate” under Obama is ridiculous. As you can see in the chart I created below, federal spending (included in GDP) has increased in every single quarter compared to March 2009, while state and local spending has dropped like a rock.

While the Times disclosed that the overall decline was due to spending reductions at the state and local level, I doubt many Americans would view a 5-10% increase in federal spending as a “slow rate” of growth, especially with their own incomes stagnating. And if the President had his way the past couple of years, these totals would be even higher.

But perhaps the most egregious point is from later in the Times piece where they suggest that overall growth, and hence poor President Obama, has suffered due to a lack of “acceleration” of government spending. Where exactly do they think the government gets the money that it spends? A dollar taxed is a dollar not spent in the private sector. After racking up an additional $5 trillion in debt since January 2009, is the Times suggesting that we should have borrowed even more?

wait